Should the Lebanese Army Be Beyond Retribution?

To start this, I feel it is important to say that I respect the Lebanese army because many will feel, upon reading this, that I’m degrading our armed forces, which is not my intention.

The purpose of this post is to ask a few questions – the answers to those questions are not set in stone. They go back to your perspective. Some might feel the answer the questions posed are yes. Others will feel the answer is a no. Either way, it’s always healthy to have a debate.

When it comes to the Lebanese army, many put it on a pedestal. Whatever the army does, you can’t criticize it, you can’t comment on its work, you can’t talk about anything it does in a negative light. The argument? The army is already doing more than what’s required of it and you have no right to criticize.

But is the argument that the army is doing more than it should enough to explain any possible shortcomings?

For instance, when it comes to neutrality, the Lebanese army is praised for keeping a distance from everyone, as it should. For instance, when Kataeb students were getting beaten up in Downtown Beirut, the army stood by and watched. I think it should have interfered because these are the people it should be protecting. Many felt that remaining neutral is better.

However, soon after that downtown incident, students were protesting at a Lebanese university as a reply to a protest that went on a week earlier. The army was neutral for the first protest – it beat up the students during the second one. Now, should we remain silent about this or do we have the right to ask: what happened?

When it comes to the checkpoints, such as the Madfoun checkpoint, is it fair to say that we are civilians who don’t understand the importance of such checkpoints? Is it fair that we don’t get to criticize why some regions have such checkpoints and not others? Or should we just “suck it up” and not get a say at all?

Should we, as civilians, not be allowed to address some military men who abuse their power, if they exist, and who might be protected by the halo we throw around them?

Should the army’s triumphs protect it from any possible inquiry people might have about its other activities?

In any other country in the world, while the military is respected, people get the chance to constructively criticize. I say, who not in Lebanon too?

4 thoughts on “Should the Lebanese Army Be Beyond Retribution?

  1. I think opening the door to criticism opens other doors that the army shouldn’t be exposed to. So yeah, for the time being, just let it be.

    Like

    Reply
  2. There are no military men that abuse there power ( speeking only in the lebanese army), there are no Hitlers or Saddams in the army and no halos and not because everybody is a saint, because we are in country that gives power to military men as much as their job requires power no more or less
    You said that the army is doing more than it is required, and its true, it also means a lot of hard work and pressure and if there is a single positive aspect between all this, is that they have the support of their people (all the people) and here you are calling people to be allowed to criticize the army
    Why the army shouldn’t be criticized???
    Not because they are sacred
    Not because you should fear them
    Not because they are untouchables
    It is because when shit happens ( and it happens a lot in our country) they are the one in the middle of it, giving blood ( literally and not a metaphor) risking their lives and away from there family and children while you are cozy and safe in your batroun house
    Why we shouldn’t critisize the army?
    For few reasons like respect and gratitude

    Like

    Reply
    • Any institution in any country shouldn’t be beyond criticism. This is the basis of the whole argument. If people make mistakes, regardless of how good they were before, shouldn’t they be told off about their mistakes?
      We have respect and gratitude towards the army. No one said otherwise.

      And I beg to differ. There are army men who abuse their power. It comes with the territory and it happens everywhere just as there are doctors who abuse their power and engineers and lawyers.

      Like

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s