Yoü and I (Single Review) – Lady Gaga

Yoü and I was just announced as the upcoming fourth single off Lady Gaga’s newest album “Born This Way.”

The song continues in the sound departure Lady Gaga has set for herself this era: more Edge of Glory than Judas, if you want – and that’s not necessarily a bad thing.

The soulful, piano-driven, 80’s rock-influenced ballad is about going back to see an old love and not wanting to let that love go. It starts: “It’s been a long time since I came around. It’s been a long time but I’m back in town and this time I’m not leaving without you.”

The lyrics leave nothing to the imagination. It is a highly personal song. Lady Gaga’s fans can easily name the person to whom this song is dedicated: her nebraska guy, who has a bar in New York. “Something, something about this place. Something about lonely nights, and my lipstick on your face. Something, something about my cool Nebraska guy.”

The song is the story of a relationship that started with a long chase: “Something, something about the chase
(Six whole years).” And ended with Lady Gaga not wanting to let him go but had to. Now, two years later, she’s back to her hometown and she’s not leaving without him, despite the relationship being tumultuous. However, she can’t get over the small gestures she loved: “On my birthday you sang me a heart of gold with a guitar humming and no clothes.”

Lady Gaga’s vocal performance on this song is one of her best. She injects the lyrics and melody with energy that takes the whole song to another level. The song could have easily been monotonous, but her nuances and injections here and there elevate it into a breathy and easy-to-listen to track.

The interesting thing about the choice of Yoü and I as a single is that, even though the album has other electropop songs that would become faster and surer hits on radio, Lady Gaga chose this “unconventional” song for pop radio. It could be that seeing the runaway success Adele is currently having, Lady Gaga has realized the electropop age is fading and is slowly trying to get listeners to get accustomed to her new intended sound. If that’s the case, I have hope her upcoming music releases would be even better and show true artistry, not just flashy gimmicks to grab attention.

Deviating away from trends is Lady Gaga’s niche. Yoü and I continues this trend and this time, it just works. The song is great. Whether radio embraces it and turns it into a big hit is another matter entirely. But it’s Lady Gaga so you know the hype will be big. And at the end of the day, a true artist knows they have a clear path to self-expression. I’m glad Lady Gaga is not worried about the risks that her path involves. But the fact of the matter is, Yoü and I wasn’t the only song off Born This Way to go top 10 on iTunes without being a single for no reason. There’s a lot of appeal behind it. Hopefully it will translate into a successful single that will continue in steering Lady Gaga in this direction.

Listen to Yoü and I:


15 thoughts on “Yoü and I (Single Review) – Lady Gaga

      • you know that I’m not a gaga fan like ‘I like every song of her, cos it’s gaga and so every song is great.’ She has her good songs and her bad songs. I really love her music, but it doesn’t mean I like every single song.
        and with this review you’re sharing my thoughts, so I agree with you 🙂


  1. Hahaha, you know what? I thought exactly the same when I was reading that part of the review, lol. Ah, let them come. You’re awesome too, so you’re beyond that crap 😉 ❤


  2. i love the album, and im not that of a maniac about Gaga, but i love her, and eagerly wait for her. But the thing is, you’ll not find me in one of her concerts dying for a touch of her hand. I might be influenced and inspired by her artistically, but only because she is giving something beautiful.
    Adele is great too, she is giving another form of art. She has a huge voice and she knows how to use it. They are both from the masters of our time (well at least in pop music) !

    the song Yoü & I is good, and im eagerly waiting what will she produce for the visuals!

    good review!


    • Well, I don’t really like the album and I’m always on the fence when it comes to Gaga. I prefer Adele by a country mile. They’re two opposites in today’s music industry: flashy theatrics vs simplicity. I like simplicity.

      I hope the video doesn’t ruin the song, since it’s a really good song 🙂
      Thank you for taking the time to read my review.


      • Hi. Speaking of simplicity, have you heard the snippet of Lady Gaga’s upcoming duet with the legend that is Tony Bennett? You can look it up on youtube, I’m pretty sure that you will LOVE it seeing as to how you are a fan (or kinda, but no. but really LOL) of “that” side of Gaga. It’s quite short, just 30 seconds of pure jazz perfection but it left me wanting for more.

        And yeah, I understand your dislike of Gaga’s theatrics, but I hope that doesn’t make you write her off completely. Though not necessarily because of her crazy antics and self-written pop songs, girl is still a rare music gem you know, as evidenced by that duet.

        (btw I am the one who commented last May 16 on this post:
        https://stateofmind13.wordpress.com/2011/05/10/edge-of-glory-single-review-lady-gaga/ in which I inserted a video of Lady Gaga singing Captivated and you promised to tell me what you thought of it but you never got around to doing it haha)


  3. Pingback: We Found Love (Single Review) – Rihanna « A Separate State of Mind

  4. Pingback: We Found Love (Single Review) – Rihanna « Norimalers's Blog

  5. Pingback: Top 13 Songs of 2011 « A Separate State of Mind

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s